Are Canadian Housing Prices at the Top?
Sunday, November 27th, 2011Over the past 10 years, Americans have witnessed the explosion of home prices across the country. Subsequently they witnessed the largest collapse in real estate prices of all time. With real estate prices remaining at historically high rates across Canada, many Canadians are wondering if the Canadian marketplace will fall victim to the same collapse as the United States.
To answer this question, we’re going to look at some of the causes of the American real estate collapse
1) Interest Only Mortgages
In the US, interest only mortgages became quite popular early in the new millennium, with many families opting to purchase homes that they really couldn’t afford, with interest only mortgages. Rather than renting, they would spend roughly the same amount on owning their own home. Unfortunately, as soon as the house prices fell slightly, this caused the momentum to continue. With people holding mortgages for more than homes were worth, it was simply in their best interest to walk away from the home and cut their losses. This compounded the problem and drove already falling housing prices even lower.
In Canada: You cannot have an interest only mortgage in Canada. Most mortgages require a 25% downpayment. Therefore, unless housing prices suddenly tumble by more than 25%, this isn’t a risk
2) Failing Economy
There have recently been major issues with the US economy, particularly as manufacturing moves overseas and factories continue to close. The US economy has lagged in recent years and is projected to continue to experience slow growth for at least the next 5 years.
In Canada: While Canada’s economy was impacted by the recession of 2008, the effects have been much more minor than in the US. Canada’s economy is based heavily on natural resources, rather than manufacturing, and therefore isn’t as volatile as the American economy.
3) Failing Banks
American banks have been failing left, right and centre. The financial industry has continued to do poorly since the 2008 collapse. In fact, this is what spurred many of the widespread occupy Wall St protests.
In Canada: Canadian banks are some of the most secure in the world.
If we look at these three triggers for the American real estate collapse, we can see that a collapse in Canada of similar magnitude is highly unlikely. Furthermore, Canada has an incredibly high immigration rate, which continues to push housing prices higher in major centres. For example, in Toronto alone, more than 40,000 new dwellings are needed each year to keep up with demand.
Overall, Canadian Real Estate prices are at an all time high, and it appears that they will continue to rise for the foreseeable future.